About Mathews Insurance, Inc.


In the 72 years Mathews has been providing Southeast Ohio with quality coverage, the insurance industry has changed dramatically. While faster quotes and funnier mascots have made the process more convenient, at Mathews we still subscribe to the philosophy that we were founded on: your insurance agent should be friendly, reliable and local.

While we are firmly planted in the beliefs that started with our company in 1945, we have also been fortunate enough to evolve with the times, now offering you the ability to request quotes and policy services online. Unlike our competition, we represent several top-quality insurance companies, giving us the flexibility to find the best insurance value to match your needs.

Are you shopping around for better insurance? Give us a call, message us on Facebook, email us, or fill out a quote request on our site. You won't speak to a robot, you won't be put on hold--you will speak to a caring human who will help you in whatever way they can.


L-R: Russ Norris, Brenda James, John Miller, Alysia Brooks, Brian Miller
Mathews crew wearing blue for Ohio Wears Blue Day 2017
Mallory and Alysia shortly after donating blood at our Blood Drive in May 2016
Mathews and Co. at the first annual Habitat for Humanity Nails It competition
Alysia Brooks modeling at the Southeast Ohio Red Cross Runway for the Red benefit show
Agent Brian Miller helped prepare the stage meals for The Taste of Home Cooking School at Stuart's Opera House in 2016
Bounty on the Bricks 2015