*Note: We will be closed for Thanksgiving beginning at Noon on Wednesday 11/22 through Friday 11/24. We will resume normal hours Monday 11/27. Thank you!

Mathews Insurance, Inc.

Choice. Dependability. Flexibility. A friend you can rely on. For your car, home, business, and life Mathews Insurance, Inc. has it all for you at one of our two locations. From our offices in Athens, Ohio and McConnelsville, Ohio we serve the insurance needs of individuals, families, and businesses in Southeastern Ohio. As an independent insurance agency, we represent many top rated insurance companies. We're here for you locally, 24/7 via our website or by calling us at the location nearest you:

Mathews Insurance, Inc Athens, Ohio (740) 593-5573

James Insurance Agency McConnelsville, Ohio (740) 962-9900

We strive to provide you with the right insurance protection, superior claim service when you need it and the essential convenience of a local office. Mathews Insurance, Inc. is proud to serve you!

Products & Service

Mathews Insurance, Inc. offers insurance products for families, individuals & businesses.

About Us

We are an independent insurance agency. What does that mean to you? Let us tell you how we marry experience, choice and convenience.
Learn More.

Personal Insurance

Car, home, condo, boat, RV - we have it all in one place and with a choice of top rated carriers to fit your protection and budget needs.
Learn More.

Business Insurance

Business serve all kinds of needs and come in all sizes. We can tailor an insurance program to fit yours.
Learn More.

Life & Health

Life & Health insurance are the foundation for any sound financial plan. We can help you find the right coverage and premium.
Learn More.


Are you looking for a specialized program for your craft beverage business? We are here to help!
Learn More.


Contractors have liability insurance needs unique to the building trade. We understand those needs and can find insurance protection to fit the budget of your business.
Learn More.

Fall Proofing: Preventing Falls Inside and Outside of the Home

According to the World Health Organization, falls are the second leading cause of accidental injury deaths worldwide. Falling disproportionately impacts adults age 65 and older, and can lead to serious injury, further health problems, decreased quality of life, and a loss of independence.

Continue Reading...

Safety for Student Drivers

Ah, freedom... if learning to drive is on the horizon for your teenager, he or she is probably thrilled about the prospect of getting to travel outside the confines of your schedule and neighborhood. You, on the other hand, might be thrilled about not having to drive them everywhere but the excitement ends there.

Continue Reading...

Our Testimonials

Delivering the best possible service means making sure we help you identify potential risks in your personal and business pursuits, finding you the right insurance coverage options and providing all that at the lowest possible price. Do we deliver? See what our clients have to say about that.

Contact Info: